1

I am building a 16x24x3 stage in a 4000 square foot warehouse, to be used principally to showcase music. A local audio guy has told me that I have to fill the wooden framed stage with sand. This appears like it is going to be very costly, so I asked about using R39 insulation instead. He said I will just end up a one big boomy speaker. Is the sand of paramount importance? We do plan to showcase some bigger acts in here. Appreciate your thoughts, and certainly would love to hear opinions on any other issues regarding the project that should be considered.

Thanks, Greg

  • 1
    Please fix the caps on the title. It looks like you're shouting. – Schizomorph Aug 14 '17 at 18:08
2

I've worked in a few large stages (<5000) people and I have never seen a stage filled with sand. The stage is usually an aluminum construction made of lite decks or even steel decks. This is usually preferred because they are versatile since you can move them around or even hire them out when you're not using them. They are used so often that they have almost become a measuring unit.

I think what your local sound guy is trying to bring your attention to is that a big wooden box will tend to resonate (that's why we use such constructions for speakers and even guitars) and that will impact the sound somewhat. Filling it with sand wouldn't work in my opinion unless the construction was really really strong and you used thick solid pieces of wood. That's because the sand will a) collect dump, b) be compacted over time with the vibrations and c) from the combination from a) and b) it will slowly deform the wood. It will also render the space under the stage useless and this is where musicians often hide their cases during the gig. I don't know what the constructions looks like structurally, but maybe you could leave all the sides open and cover them with black (or whatever color) fabrics. We call those skirts. They allow access (you will often need to run cables under it) and you can do whatever you want as far as looks go on the front while not losing access from the sides/back.

You will find that some audio guys will place their subs on the front and that's another reason to leave it open or covered with skirts. This will allow the bass some space before reflecting off the back wall. Not that the wood of the stage would do a great lot to a wavelength of more than a meter.

  • Thanks for your input. So perhaps even using these 4x8 pre-fab aluminum stage risers I have seen, would be okay? – Greg Eichman Aug 15 '17 at 20:38
  • Yes. I think those 4x8 are the most common size. What's the ground like? If it's concrete or something hard, you're ok. If it's dirt though you will need 1x1 ft bits of wood to keep the legs from sinking when people are jumping on them and also to make it level. – Schizomorph Aug 15 '17 at 21:31
  • Appreciate your help, Schizo. Do you think a steel deck construction would be any advantage over the premade folding aluminum pieces? – Greg Eichman Aug 16 '17 at 17:56
  • I can't really think of any. Unless you are expecting really heavy loads. But then again the plywood would probably fail before the aluminum or steel. – Schizomorph Aug 16 '17 at 18:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.