2

I am recording some speech (for voiceover purposes) and have noticed two issues with the input that I wish to correct:

  1. There is a persistent hiss. The Noise Reduction effect appears to deal with it, more or less.
  2. Since I cut and paste the final output, my audio volume is not always constant. I am trying to use the Speech Volume Leveler effect to correct this.

The result that I get after applying these two steps is that moments of silence in the audio file get their light remaining hiss greatly amplified. My desired goal is to leave silent moments as-is and just level the parts with meaningful content.

Adobe documentation appears to support the idea that background noise is not meant to get louder, so this is perpelxing.

The Amplitude and Compression > Speech Volume Leveler is a compression effect that optimizes dialogue, evening out levels and removing background noise.

Here are some example files that demonstrate the issue.

Am I doing something wrong process-wise?

  • 1
    if there's noise in the background and you are compressing , of course you are doing something wrong (and stupid) . Software companies often tell you that they can remove the background noise by compressing (this is an outrageous statement). /// If you have noise in the background use a gate and place your microphone / fix your room accordingly, if you have noise created after the input in your card , change your card // if you have noise created in the DAW (which i find hard to believe) use a compander with pre emphasis and de emphasis (check dbx denoiser and how it works) – frcake Jun 24 '16 at 6:29
1

First of all, you are making a fundamental error which is resulting in a higher noise level. This error is with your recording levels. The level of your voice is too low during recording.

Secondly, you have DC bias(offset) occurring somewhere in your system. This lowers the highest level your voice can be recorded at. Again, the result is a higher noise level.

If you sort these two things out, you should have a much better starting point to work from. From there, I suggest you use the 'Noise Reduction Process...' with a 'noise print' of an isolated section of noise from your recording.

As for the SVL, read my answer to this question regarding scrapping it.

Good Luck.

  • 1
    try to use a broadband phase rotator , it will give +6 db to a male voice recording with the classic asymetry. – frcake Jun 24 '16 at 6:34
1

A "speech volume leveler" is just a fancy name for some proprietary algorithm they've cooked up to try to make things simpler for the amateur user.

The basic, building block tools to control your levels here are a compressor and an expander. You'll probably need both. Apply the expander first. If you set the threshold and other attributes correctly, all signals that are louder than the noise floor will be boosted, and in comparison the noise will be much less present especially in quiet moments between sentences. This will still leave some parts of the audio louder and others (your initial issue, that the level is not always constant). However a simple compressor can help to address this. Adjust the threshold till you get your louder parts a bit squashed, I suppose. I use volume automation and apply compression as lightly as I can get away with, as it will affect the character of the sound.

Note I did not download your original files because I didn't desire to install an unknown downloading client on my computer. My advice though is basic common sense audio practice that can come in handy in dealing with any vocal recording with any level of noise.

A noise reducer is another good plugin to apply lightly but it is a filter, and it won't in itself solve all your dynamic problems.

  • 1
    You didn't have to install the client, just click ~"Download using browser". – Marc W Sep 29 '15 at 0:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.