I've been recording reggae/ska in GarageBand, using a combination of:

  • Voice through a condenser mic
  • Electric guitar and bass using GarageBand's own amp simulators and effects
  • Drum patterns programmed using GarageBand's kits
  • Software organ

I play all the parts live, and avoid quantising.

It sounds OK, but a bit sterile. Listening to classic ska tracks that influence me (say, anything from the Trojan Ska boxed set) what seems to characterise the sound most is a benign fuzziness, presumably distortion that engineers tried and failed to avoid using what equipment a 1960s Jamaican studio could afford.

Question one is: how can I replicate that sound using the equipment I have

Question two is: how can I achieve that feel without going so extremely lo-fi.

  • You use programmed drum patterns and then ask about feel? Commented Jan 11, 2012 at 0:59
  • Drums are a whole 'nother problem; but let's put them aside for the purposes of this question.
    – slim
    Commented Jan 11, 2012 at 10:12

2 Answers 2


Part of the vintage feel of those old records is in (1) the kind of mastering that was done for cheaply produced vinyl records, and (2) the wear-and-tear that they have sustained over the years. Even if you have only heard "remastered" digital versions, if the original was on a fly-by-night Caribbean indy it may have been remastered from the best available vinyl rather than the master tapes.

Mastering for vinyl rolled off a lot of low frequencies and compressed/limited the dynamic range. Age and multiple plays of a record start rolling off the highs and adding noise.

So a mix buss comp/limiter, roll off lows below 100 Hz (experiment), highs above 5k (experiment), and add a "vinyl noise crackle" plugin if you feel like it. It ain't "vibe in a bottle" but it might be interesting.

  • Thanks. I hear some fuzzy resonance on the higher horns and vocals. My synaesthetic side wants to say it "blooms", like a bloom filter on a photograph. Any idea where that comes from / how to replicate?
    – slim
    Commented Jan 12, 2012 at 11:13
  • tubes and tape.
    – datageist
    Commented Jan 13, 2012 at 21:18

Garage Band has a couple of Fuzz Pedals. They're intended to be used as guitar effects, but you might be able to tweak them to get the sound you're after.

  • 1
    A Fuzz Pedal is a particular type of extreme distortion, usually used as a guitar effect. Not likely to be useful to apply to an overall mix in this context.
    – Bill Gribble
    Commented Jan 11, 2012 at 21:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.