1

I had to record someone whistling for a sound effect on a film I worked on recently.

That was really hard to record.

I tried different mics... About 10 of them...

I finally ended up with a C12 pointed at the guy's cheek about 2 feet away from him...

Has anyone had any success in recording someone whistling without it sounding really hard on the ears? And how did you do it!

3

I'm sure the technique would be incredibly similar to recording flute, for the same reasons. From a few feet away, and outside the direct flow of air.

2

I went to see the Marsalis family (and I do mean the whole family) at the Kennedy Center here in, DC earlier this year...I think it was this year...not a good sign...anyway...

One of them can whistle better than anyone you've ever heard. He was amazing, and he was just using a handheld mic about 8 inches from his chest and level with his throat. I wish I knew what model mic, or what the pick-up pattern was. That's all the info I can give you on that experience.

I'll have to try it out myself sometime.

  • I'll bet it was a supersupersupersupermegamondohyper cardioid. – Utopia Aug 10 '10 at 0:57
  • @Ryan - i don't know. he was pretty damned loud. even and omni might have worked. lol – Shaun Farley Aug 10 '10 at 1:02
  • Well, maybe part of why it sounds so harsh to me is I'm getting the room too much, so I tended to try a cardioid as much as possible to make it sound smoother. You know how you can record a chainsaw somewhat pleasantly with an SM57? Same concept. – Utopia Aug 10 '10 at 5:02
  • @Ryan - lol, i've never had the pleasure of recording chainsaws. but i'll remember that if i ever get the chance. – Shaun Farley Aug 10 '10 at 11:57

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.