3

As I am working through a scene, and contemplating this question on my own, I thought it wise to tap into the experiential resource that is SocialSoundDesign.... Let's get your insight!

The sound: Ambient "battlefield panic" to accompany several (and I mean SEVERAL) scenes throughout an American Civil War documentary. Cannon shots, men screaming, horses, more cannon shots....the works!

The situation: The most distinct sound in this scape is, of course, the cannon and gunshots. I have a limited selection of raw samples of each to work with. ...and no, I am not in a position to create any more of my own. That opportunity has passed.

Do I, A) use only a few of the best sounds MANY, MANY times each (going loony with Pitch, and TCE to change it up), or B) do I use a variety of my available samples regardless of tone, perspective, and timbre?

I'm leaning toward a mixture of the two options, emphasis on option A. The real question here may be: Which will an audience notice less - repeated fx, or mismatched timbre?

2

I would go with variety, but do it in a sneaky way. Layering sounds together will benefit the end result, meaning layering and combining the good with the bad. If your samples are in stereo I would re-import the layered sounds in mono, this way you can easily pan them to match the location of the original sound. You can stack up a bunch of samples, even from different source material, you'll just need to adjust the volume and add reverb (you should bus the mono track to a stereo reverb) to make it seamless. I think in this situation layering and spotting sounds is your best bet to create a varied and believable environment.

1

I think I would personally go for your second option- so long as the samples aren't really terrible- I think a wider variety is important. and surely tone, timbre and perspective would change anyway if there are cannons at different distances etc?

0

Another vote here for variety. Years ago there was a very good British TV documentary series called 'The World at War' about WW2. It used a lot of archive footage of battle scenes but had the same sound effects over and over again - the same rocket barrage or ricocheting bullet. This was quite noticeable.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.