Update (8/15/10): the first challenge is up.
Sorry about creating a new post for this, but it's getting hard to keep track of where all the feedback is for this thing (some in the first thread, but there are a bunch floating around as comments in other threads too). So, here it is.
When I provide a video for the competition, and it already has real world audio, would you prefer to get the video with or without that audio?
I've spent a fair bit of time researching/gathering for this month's challenge. I had to pass up my first choice, because I was unable to secure permission. Thankfully, I found a suitable replacement (it might even be better). This question would have applied to either one.
If you're curious as to what might have been, you can view it here: http://www.archive.org/details/FootballAccident
I'm still not telling you what the challenge was gonna be, because I may still use the idea either this month or in some future challenge.
Thanks for any input you guys offer.