Take the 2-minute tour ×
Sound Design Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for sound engineers, producers, editors, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'm using Sonar LE to record a station ID for a little online radio station experiment I'm trying to set up. I've learnt to use a compressor to increase the volume of individual tracks without peaking above 0 dB. I've also applied some compression on the master as suggested here. But the final mix still sounds awfully quiet compared to just about any music file I have on my computer.

Here are my tracks along with their peak volume, volume adjustment and applied effects:

Tracks

My final mix compression settings are as follows:

Final mix compression

What can I do to further pump the volume? I don't need it to be obnoxiously loud; I just don't want it to sound too quiet compared to the music on the playlist like it currently does.

share|improve this question
add comment

migrated from avp.stackexchange.com Jan 24 at 12:01

This question came from our site for engineers, producers, editors, and enthusiasts spanning the fields of video, and media creation.

2 Answers

up vote 1 down vote accepted

A limiter is the most brutal form of a compressor, you should use one (at the very end of the FX chain) but I wouldn't let it do too much, it can really start to sound annoying quite quickly. Before it, try just driving the present compressors a bit harder, i.e. any of higher ratio, lower threshold and lower attack. And of course gain makeup – you did actually check that the signal does go to the allowed maximum? Note that individual tracks may in fact exceed the limit, not a real problem if there's a compressor and limiter in the master track.

There are a lot of more special things one can to in dynamic processing:

  • Try putting two (or more) normal compressor units in a row. Thereby, you can get higher total ratios without too obvious action of any of them.
  • Lookahead. That's a feature of many digital compressors which allows them to remove fast peaks far more rigorously without need to set the attack so low that it sounds bad.
  • Output level detection (also something the Cakewalk compressor doesn't seem to be capable of). This allows the compressor to actually control the output level, rather than simply react on the input level; usually performs better in terms of master loudness.
  • Multiband compression.

Hang on here: before starting with that, you should make sure you've also set the equalizers really well. Specifically, from what's visible in the picture, there might be a lot of low-frequency junk around, which may substantially raise the levels without adding anything useful to the sound. Don't be afraid to use hard highpass filters! And try boosting mid frequencies that are "loud" and well-comprehensible but won't raise the signal level too much. Ok, where were we...

  • Multiband compression. You probably didn't want to say too much of the bass goodbye, then these bass frequencies will not only raise the output levels but, of course, also drive the compressors, thereby reducing the level of all frequencies. A multiband compressor lets you compress the different frequency ranges seperately, so each can be maximized on its own.
  • Nonlinear distortion. That's right! It's the oldest trick of all: "if that guitar amp won't get me loud enough inside the clean range, I'll just drive it over the limit". You can get a signal much louder by simply clipping it over 0dB, but it will obviously have a rather strong... influence on the sound. In particular, digital and in general OP-based electronics peak very harshly, resulting in rather unacceptable artifacts. That was different in "old" analog equipment, which saturates far more subtly. One piece of such equipment that is therefore still found in most studios is the tube microphone preamp. Rather more effective used to be the analog tape machine. The are today plugins which can simulate the characteristics of such devices, or simply give you the kind of benefits they offer. For instance, mastering multiband compressor and limiter tend to have such a soft clip unit built in. You still want to be careful with such stuff as it can literally destroy audio signals if done too strongly, but IMO it tends to sound more natural than directly driving a limiter too hard.
share|improve this answer
    
This allows the compressor to actually control the output level, rather than simply react on the input level; usually performs better in terms of master loudness. I found this VST plugin, a multiband compressor. It lets me maximize the loudness without going over 0 dB. What are your thoughts on this approach? I think it sounds good except that my voice still seems to have a little distortion going on. If you have the time, the recording is here. Be warned... I'm not a native speaker. –  Pieter Feb 19 '12 at 13:44
    
Here is the effect chain for the voice track. I did a high pass filter at 100 Hz to filter out the low frequency stuff. Then I used the Cakewalk compressor with these settings. –  Pieter Feb 19 '12 at 13:47
    
@Pieter that sounds pretty good to me. There is indeed quite an audible amount of distortion, perhaps you want to lower the gain on the vocal compressor just a little again. I think you can then use it this way. For some more plugins you might try: I really like the ones included in Reaper, which are also available independently. –  leftaroundabout Feb 19 '12 at 14:29
add comment

I would suggest using a limiter instead of a compressor. While they're both very similar, a limiter can do what you need much quicker and efficiently.

Try taking the compressor off your master out and put a limiter in its place. Drop the threshold so it's always tripped, raise the out ceiling to desired volume, adjust the release, done. Pay attention to the gain reduction meter and try to time it with the sound so it doesn't sound like it's "pumping" or "breathing".

Some people would groan at this methodology, saying it isn't the best sounding option, but I say that in situations like this it's utility over sound quality.

share|improve this answer
1  
No need to take away the compressor, I'd leave that in too to give the limiter a little knee before its brickwall. –  leftaroundabout Feb 18 '12 at 22:05
    
I've tinkered with the settings of Cakewalk's limiter, but I'm getting better results with a multiband processor mentioned here. Am I correct in assuming that everything above Limiter Thr is dialed down with Output Gain decibels? –  Pieter Feb 19 '12 at 16:43
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.